Trump Loses Bid To Dismiss Accuser's Defamation Lawsuit

Summer Zervos a former contestant
'These are sick people' | President Trump breaks silence on Austin, Schertz bombings
Author

21 March, 2018

A NY judge on Tuesday ruled that President Donald Trump must face a defamation suit brought by a former contestant on "The Apprentice" who accused him in 2016 of making unwanted sexual advances.

The ruling could force Trump to submit to questioning by lawyers for Zervos and lead to further public scrutiny of other claims of sexual misconduct that have been made against the president.

A NY state judge on Tuesday denied a bid by Trump to toss a defamation lawsuit by Summer Zervos, a former contestant on NBC's "The Apprentice", raising the prospect that he might have to answer questions about his behaviour in court.

Adds the judge, "Nothing in the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution even suggests that the President can not be called to account for wrongful conduct that bears no relationship to any federal executive responsibility".

Though the president sought to have the defamation case either dismissed or put on hold until he leaves office, Judge Schechter found today that Trump's new title offers him no such privilege.

Zervos remained quiet about the attacks but made a decision to break her silence about the attacks in October 2016, in the weeks leading up to the presidential election, after the release of the "Access Hollywood" tape in which Trump could be heard engaging in a lewd discussion about women, including forms of sexual assault.

McDougal filed her lawsuit in Los Angeles Superior Court against American Media Inc, publisher of the National Enquirer, whose head, David Pecker, has described Trump as a "personal friend".

Trump's separate argument that his comments represented "pure political speech" and couldn't rise to defamatory statements is also rejected.

Russian Federation to expel 23 United Kingdom diplomats
A British policeman was also poisoned when he went to help them and remains in a serious but stable condition. Thursday saw an exchange of openly insulting language between British and Russian ministers.

Photo A Manhattan judge said on Tuesday that a former contestant on "The Apprentice" can proceed with her lawsuit against President Trump.

Kasowitz cited Clinton v. Jones, a 1997 U.S. Supreme Court opinion, which determined that presidents aren't immune from civil actions in federal court but had a footnote where Justice John Paul Stevens wrote that it was "not necessary to consider or decide whether a comparable claim might succeed in a state tribunal".

"Nothing in the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution even suggests that the president can not be called to account before a state court for wrongful conduct that bears no relationship to any federal executive responsibility", Schecter found.

Zervos said that after appearing on Trump's show in 2006 she asked him for a job.

Marc Kasowitz of Kasowitz Benson Torres, who is representing Trump in the case, said in December at oral arguments for the motion to dismiss that Trump's statements on the issue amounted to overheated campaign rhetoric-and thus can not be construed as defamatory-and that none of the statements explicitly named Zervos. On Tuesday, Judge Jennifer Schecter sided with Zervos.

Maria Glover, a law professor at Georgetown University, said that the decision will nearly certainly go to appeal.

Although Trump now must respond in court to the complaint, an immediate appeal is highly likely. "His statements can be proven true or false, as they pertain to whether [Zervos] made up allegations to pursue her own agenda", Schecter also said.

Daniels shared her story with InTouch magazine in 2011, but the interview was not published until the Wall Street Journal reported on the affair and payout earlier this year.


More news


  • Stenson takes 1-shot lead at Bay Hill

    Stenson takes 1-shot lead at Bay Hill

    The third-round 69 breaks a small string of third-round improvement during Woods' three previous made cuts this year. Henrik Stenson has another chance to win at Bay Hill, and he made it a little bit tougher on Tiger Woods.
    Apple to host education-themed event at Lane Tech

    Apple to host education-themed event at Lane Tech

    Apple is holding an education-focused event later this month to "hear creative new ideas for teachers and students". The world seems to love a big Apple event, so mark your cards for March 27, which is when the next one is happening.
    Red State Dems Can't Love Trump, So They Love His Tariffs Instead

    Red State Dems Can't Love Trump, So They Love His Tariffs Instead

    Brown praised Trump Tuesday for foisting steep 10 and 25 percent tariffs on aluminum and steel products, respectively. But the real target of the steel and aluminum tariffs is China.
  • Los Alamitos rejects CA state sanctuary law

    Los Alamitos rejects CA state sanctuary law

    Many cities have faced the ire of Trump and his administration for policies they say are too lenient toward those here illegally. The Shasta County Board of Supervisors passed a resolution last month saying the county isn't a sanctuary jurisdiction.
    Jose Mourinho SLAUGHTERS Frank de Boer after Marcus Rashford criticism

    Jose Mourinho SLAUGHTERS Frank de Boer after Marcus Rashford criticism

    He has won trophies, is tactically very strong, knows how to disrupt the game of every opponent. I said that before the Liverpool match when many of you were maybe not expecting him to start.
    Snow and ice warning extended through weekend

    Snow and ice warning extended through weekend

    He said: "We don't expect anything like the same impact as a result of it, although there will be some snow about". Met Office meteorologist Mark Wilson said: "The best way to describe this is a real return to wintry conditions".
  • President Trump to Remove National Security Adviser HR McMaster?

    President Trump to Remove National Security Adviser HR McMaster?

    They are eager to show that someone can serve in the Trump administration without suffering severe damage to his reputation. As my colleague Gabe Sherman reported this week, Trump has chose to oust National Security Adviser H.R.
    When will the sales of Toys 'R' Us locations begin?

    When will the sales of Toys 'R' Us locations begin?

    Toys R Us says it will honor existing gift cards, as well as its Rewards dollars and Endless Earnings, for another 30 days. Toys "R" Us bought FAO Schwarz in 2009 but it was later sold to consumer products company ThreeSixtyGroup in 2016.
    Met Opera Fires James Levine, Music Director Emeritus Accused Of Sexual Abuse

    Met Opera Fires James Levine, Music Director Emeritus Accused Of Sexual Abuse

    Levine called the accusations "unfounded", saying in a statement that "I have not lived my life as an oppressor or an aggressor". He said that at one point Levine had the group don blindfolds and masturbate partners they could not see.
  • Another nor'easter could dump more snow over ME  this week

    Another nor'easter could dump more snow over ME this week

    Keep checking back with Severe Weather Team 11 on wpxi.com for updated forecasts as this storm system develops and approaches. The snow's weight will likely mean more trees and power lines falling, causing outages throughout the area, Simpson said.
    These Are Actually Prince Harry And Meghan Markle's Real Names

    These Are Actually Prince Harry And Meghan Markle's Real Names

    A similar letter was signed by Her Majesty just one week before the 2011 wedding of Prince William and Kate Middleton . Harry served in Afghanistan from 2007 to 2008 and again from 2012 to 2013 before leaving the military in June 2015.
    Trump personal assistant dismissed, joins '20 campaign

    Trump personal assistant dismissed, joins '20 campaign

    McEntee's departure has several of Trump's closest advisers anxious about the effects on the president's mood. However, dozens of White House officials are believed to still be working without full clearances.