DNA diet tests can not prophesy who will lose more weight

FOODISM360 Unsplash
FOODISM360 Unsplash
Author

22 February, 2018

Gardner further said that everybody knew the story about the diet, it was a hit, but the same diet did not work for somebody else.

"Unfortunately, it still remains unclear which diet is the best for weight loss, and who the true demons really are ... carbs or fat", she says.

Lead study author Christopher Gardner, the director of nutrition studies at the Stanford Prevention Research Center, noted that the point of the study wasn't to compare a low-fat diet to a low-carb one to see which was best for weight loss, as many previous studies have done.

Professor Gardner recruited 609 participants between the ages of 18 and 50 for his tests. Craig Pickering of DNAFit said that genes besides the three in the Stanford study can contribute to weight loss as well as fat loss and gain, as a small 2007 study found, and that it is "putting the finishing touches" on a study showing that "subjects on a genetically matched diet lost more weight" than did those on a one-size-fits-all low-carb diet. The other group went low-fat, starting with no more than 20 grams of fat per day, the equivalent to a handful of nuts.

After that they added back five to 15 grams of fat or carbs gradually, aiming to reach a balance they believed they could maintain for the rest of their lives.

By the end of the study, the researchers found variations in the results.

At the end of the year, people on a low-fat diet reported a daily average fat intake of 57 grams while those on low-carb diets consumed about 132 grams of carbs per day.

The study participants were not told to count calories or anything, but had to limit either their fat or carbohydrate intake.

Flood watch issued into Tuesday morning
The potholes on numerous roads may also be filled with water, which also requires motorists to slow down in some areas. By Saturday , up to 6 inches of rain is forecast in several rounds of precipitation across much of the state.

Before they embarked on the study, each participant had part of their genome sequenced and their baseline insulin outputs measured.

A recent trend in healthy eating circles has been a "genotype" diet.

"We told everybody they should buy whole foods. Also, we advised them to diet in a way that didn't make them feel hungry or deprived - otherwise it's hard to maintain the diet in the long run", said Gardner.

In a 600-person, year-long study, the two eating styles helped dieters drop nearly exactly the same number of pounds - and there didn't seem to be much rhyme or reason as to who succeeded on which plan, explains study author Christopher Gardner, director of nutrition studies at the Stanford Prevention Research Center. However, some lost as much as 50-60 pounds.

Further, vast weight loss variability was observed among the participants of both the groups. Contrary to what they suspected, there were no associations between the genotype pattern or insulin levels and weight loss. His research team is "continuing to delve into their databanks, now asking if the microbiome, epigenetics or a different gene expression pattern can clue them in to why there's such drastic variability between dieting individuals", it continues.

For you the reader, the biggest takeaways would be that there isn't a clear-cut victor between low-fat and low-carb. In fact, it's an idea that's taken off in recent years, with companies promoting "DNA diets" that will help you shed pounds. "Eat less sugar, less refined flour and as many vegetables as possible".

Even though cutting calories wasn't a goal for these dieters, people might still achieve this by replacing junk food with healthier alternatives, said Kevin Hall, a researcher at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases who wasn't involved in the study.

"I'm hoping that we can come up with signatures of sorts", he added.


More news


  • Red Sox Land Big Name Slugger With Massive Contract

    Red Sox Land Big Name Slugger With Massive Contract

    Martinez tied a major league record by hitting 16 home runs in September alone, batting.404 during that stretch. Gennett hit.295 a year ago and set career bests with 27 homers and 97 RBIs in his first season with the Reds.

    USA drops another game to Canada 2-1 in the Olympics

    The Americans got on the board on the first shift of the third period, when Coyne scored five-hole on an end-to-end rush. Slovenia made a hard push, the Americans played on their heels and a promising night ended in disappointment.
    NCAA Tournament 2018: Selection committee releases top 4 seeds for each region

    NCAA Tournament 2018: Selection committee releases top 4 seeds for each region

    The rankings could certainly change before the field of 68 is selected on March 11 with more than 1,000 games yet to be played. Auburn's only losses this season have come against teams rated 17th (Texas A&M), 33rd (Alabama) and 39th in the RPI (Temple).
  • Conservative Backbenchers Remind Theresa May of Vulnerability on Brexit

    Conservative Backbenchers Remind Theresa May of Vulnerability on Brexit

    A group of more than 60 Conservative MPs have signed a letter setting out their demands for the next phase of talks with the EU. She will then set out her detailed plans in a speech likely to come next week, before formal trade talks begin in March.
    Watson claims third PGA win at Riviera

    Watson claims third PGA win at Riviera

    A birdie at the par-five first on Sunday looked promising, but three bogeys on the front nine left him trailing at the turn. This is the 11th time Watson has held at least a share of the 54-hole lead, recording three victories in those instances.
    Marco Asensio: 'Real Madrid are in a good moment'

    Marco Asensio: 'Real Madrid are in a good moment'

    Goals from Ronaldo, Marco Asensio (2), Ramos and Benzema gave Madrid all three points over Real Betis at the Benito Villamarin . Ronaldo scored again as Madrid overcame Real Betis 5-3 in LaLiga on Sunday.
  • 'It was my worst nightmare'

    'It was my worst nightmare'

    It wasn't the only wardrobe malfunction on Olympic ice so far. "It is not what we get ready for when we train". British ice dancer Penny Coomes relies on body tape and safety pins to keep her colourful costumes in place.
    Supreme Court refuses to hear challenge to California gun law

    Supreme Court refuses to hear challenge to California gun law

    The Supreme Court is rejecting two challenges by guns rights groups to California laws regulating firearms' sales. In a blistering 14-page dissent , Thomas ripped the Supreme Court and California's 9th U.S.
    One more day of snow coming

    One more day of snow coming

    A Winter Weather Advisory remains in effect for portions of the eastern plains, mountains and Palmer Divide until Sunday morning. The National Weather Service expects light amounts, but falling temperatures may lead to a glaze on our roadways.
  • Toy Story Land opening this summer at Disney World

    Toy Story Land opening this summer at Disney World

    This is in combination with the already popular carnival ride Toy Story Mania! that premiered in 2008. Here are the four major attractions that will be present at Disney World's Toy Story Land .
    UN reports of 10000 civilian casualties in Afghanistan in 2017

    UN reports of 10000 civilian casualties in Afghanistan in 2017

    The capital remained a top target, with 16 percent of all casualties during the year - a total of 1,831 people killed and wounded - occurring in Kabul alone.
    WordPress plugin hacked to mine cryptocurrency: government, ICO, NHS sites hit

    WordPress plugin hacked to mine cryptocurrency: government, ICO, NHS sites hit

    The attacker added malicious code to the file to use the browser CPU in an attempt to illegally generate cryptocurrency. Texthelp said it was investigating the matter and described the breach of its system as a " criminal act ".