Supreme Court Says Lawmakers Discriminated Against Black Voters In North Carolina

Supreme Court Rejects 2 Congressional Districts In North CarolinaMore
Supreme Court Rejects 2 Congressional Districts In North CarolinaMore
Author

24 May, 2017

The justices upheld a lower court's February 2016 ruling that threw out two majority-black U.S. House of Representatives districts.

On Monday, in a 5-3 decision, the court upheld a ruling that two congressional districts were illegal racial gerrymanders. They sided with state officials that the district was drawn for political gain not to disenfranchise black voters. Right? I mean, that's the question the district court was trying to answer.

"We have the utmost respect for the Supreme Court, but it is challenging for our lawmakers to draw congressional districts that the courts will accept when the courts regularly change the rules state legislatures must follow when drawing them", said Amy Auth, a spokeswoman for North Carolina Senate Leader Phil Berger.

"North Carolina's congressional districts have frequently been used as an example as some of the most gerrymandered maps in the country", he said.

That is one of the most important parts of the decision, said Richard Pildes, an election law expert at New York University.

The contested districts were both held by black Democrats. Bob Rucho, argued that the 12 District was drawn the way it was to pack Democrats, not African-Americans, into it. It's been progressing. It went from a tool being used by conservatives to stop the creation of majority-minority districts to now a tool to try to pull these Republican gerrymanders in southern states. At the time, progressives viewed Shaw and its predecessors as an assault on the VRA-a Republican effort to prevent states from helping black voters choose their own representatives.

North Carolina lawmakers had drawn district lines such that District one and District 12 had increases of voting-age African-Americans by four percentage points and seven percentage points, respectively. The Tar Heel State GOP argued that this move was constitutional, since they were not diluting the influence of black voters for the sake of racial discrimination, but merely for that of partisan advantage.

"This is a watershed moment in the fight to end racial gerrymandering", stated Eric H. Holder Jr., chairman of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee.

Robert Lighthizer sworn in as US Trade Representative
Lighthizer has worked in Washington since the early 1970s, during which he served as the Senate Finance Committee's chief counsel and staff director.

"The evidence at trial - including live witness testimony subject to credibility determinations - adequately supports the District Court's conclusion that race, not politics, accounted for District 12's reconfiguration", Kagan wrote.

Reverend William Barber, the president of the North Carolina NAACP - who is leaving that post shortly to revive Dr. Martin Luther King's Poor People's Campaign - said that the ruling shows that the state "engaged in systemic racism and cheated to win elections", according to the Associated Press.

States reconsider districts following each census, and the endeavor is a political football.

The split among the justices was over the 12th district.

Justices Samuel Alito, Anthony Kennedy, and Chief Justice John Roberts dissented on the 12 district lines. Justice Clarence Thomas sided with the more liberal Justices Elena Kegan, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor.

Justice Neil Gorsuch, who had not yet joined the court when arguments in the case were heard in December, did not participate in the ruling. The Republican legislature explained its shape by saying it was based on partisan, not racial, concerns. It did that by adding mostly black voters to the district from the heavily black neighborhood of Durham and creating a district that now was majority black instead of a district with a substantial but minority share of black voters. "W$3 e further uphold the District Court's decision that ยง2 of the VRA gave North Carolina no good reason to reshuffle voters due to their race", the opinion states.

Nevertheless, Monday's ruling is a significant victory in a state that has been ground zero in the battle over voting rights. States are generally not allowed to use race as the predominant factor in drawing district lines.


More news


  • Rouhani, a man of the Islamic Revolution, opens Iran to West

    Rouhani, a man of the Islamic Revolution, opens Iran to West

    Ebrahim Raeisi ended the second with 38.29 percent of the ballots equal to over 15 million votes. And on Saturday, the Iranian people gave the more cosmopolitan candidate a decisive victory .
    'Twin Peaks' Is Back, As Strange And Stunning As Ever

    'Twin Peaks' Is Back, As Strange And Stunning As Ever

    In the second season finale of Twin Peaks , murdered Laura Palmer tells FBI Agent Dale Cooper that she will see him in 25 years. When Cooper momentarily escapes the Black Lodge and floats inside the box, we understand that it is connected to his past.
    Kylie Jenner Looks Just Like Kim Kardashian in Latest Outfit

    Kylie Jenner Looks Just Like Kim Kardashian in Latest Outfit

    Kylie Cosmetics went live in 2016 after the mass success she found with her lip kits. But I'm not totally innocent because I am keeping up this lifestyle.
  • OPEC set to prolong oil cuts as delegates predict smooth meeting

    Higher crude prices would retard growth rate which will result in slowing down the demand of crude oil . Since the start of the production cut, global oil prices have stabilized at around $50 per barrel.
    Do Analysts See Any Upside to Foot Locker, Inc. (NYSE:FL)?

    Do Analysts See Any Upside to Foot Locker, Inc. (NYSE:FL)?

    ILLEGAL ACTIVITY WARNING: This piece of content was first published by Chaffey Breeze and is the property of of Chaffey Breeze. In other news, SVP Paulette Alviti sold 8,000 shares of the company's stock in a transaction on Thursday, April 20th.
    Gisele Bundchen: Tom Brady had a concussion last year

    Gisele Bundchen: Tom Brady had a concussion last year

    Going by what he said a few days ago it appears that he plans on making good of his promise to fans. On Wednesday Bundchen told reporters, "He had a concussion previous year ".
  • Sweden drops Assange prosecution but British police say he still faces arrest

    Sweden drops Assange prosecution but British police say he still faces arrest

    Swedish prosecutors have dropped their long-running investigation into rape claims made against WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange. The news came down this morning about the Swedish Government dropping the rape investigation against Assange.
    New Zealand's Reid to miss Confederations Cup after knee surgery

    New Zealand's Reid to miss Confederations Cup after knee surgery

    In contrast, West Ham United were seen as outsiders for a potential European spot after finishing seventh last season . With Winston Reid out injured , Ireland U21 global Declan Rice could make his Premier League debut this weekend.
    Spirit Realty Capital, Inc. (SRC) Closed at $7.11

    Spirit Realty Capital, Inc. (SRC) Closed at $7.11

    Maximum and minimum EPS estimate for the current quarter is projected at $0.08 and $0.06, respectively, according to 6 analysts. Cornerstone Wealth Management LLC raised its stake in shares of Spirit Realty Capital by 0.5% in the first quarter.
  • Trump, Moon to Meet 'as Soon as Possible'

    Iranian President Hassan Rouhani has extended his congratulations to Moon Jae-in for winning South Korea's presidential election. Katherine Moon is a Korea expert with the Center for East Asia Policy Studies at the Brookings Institution in Washington, D.C.

    BofA Pushes For Lower Mortgage Down Payments

    At the current average 30-year fixed mortgage rate of 4.15 percent, the monthly payment for a $200,000 loan is $972.21. Interestingly, none of this week's respondents predict a rebound in mortgage rates in the next seven days.
    Japan approves law to let emperor abdicate

    Japan approves law to let emperor abdicate

    Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's Cabinet approved legislation Friday allowing Japan's emperor to abdicate the throne. But there is no provision under the existing law for him to abdicate and be succeeded by Crown Prince Naruhito.